I’d like to know more about visualization in 3d, VR, and AR. My general impression is (1) lots of people think putting data visualizations in 3d is often not useful (2) data visualization community is starting to experiment with 3d in VR and having more early success than 3d on flat screen. Is that true? Are there good summaries of research results into 3d visualization? My group has done some experiments with graphs in VR and, at least in terms of personal experience, found the more immersive element helps prolong user interaction compared to same graph in 2d or 3d on screen. We’re interested in how to design better network layouts for VR and better user interfaces to prompt interactive attribute assignment to help end users design the experience for their questions.